PennySleeve
You

Base Set Machamp, the odd one out

Base Set has sixteen holo rares, and fifteen of them came in booster packs. The sixteenth, Machamp, did not. It was the draw of the 2-Player Starter Set, and that one choice gave the card more quirks than any other in the set: a 1st Edition stamp it never lost, a print of its own, a non-holo twin that was never sold, a cosmos holofoil copy that turned up in the wrong boxes and, online, a version that never existed at all.

Only in the starter set

The 2-Player Starter Set held two 30-card half decks, one built on Fighting Pokémon and one on Fire, with a rulebook and damage counters, and one card more: a holo Machamp, the only Stage 2 Pokémon in the box. Put the two halves together, the box said, take out a card you won't miss, and Machamp makes a full 60-card deck. Machamp was in no Base Set booster pack, and the back of the box made the most of it.

The back of a 2-Player Starter Set box, picturing Machamp beside the words "First Edition holographic Machamp card in each box. Available only in the starter set!"
The back of a 2-Player Starter Set box: "First Edition holographic Machamp card in each box. Available only in the starter set!" Scan: Bulbapedia

1st Edition, every time

The rest of Base Set dropped the 1st Edition stamp after its first print run (Bulbapedia). Machamp never did. Every Machamp sold in a starter set carries the stamp, from the set's first printing to its last, so there is no Unlimited holo Machamp (Bulbapedia, Elite Fourum).

That doesn't make every copy the same card. The starter set's first printing was shadowless, like Base Set's first booster packs: no drop shadow beside the picture's window, and thinner lettering for the HP and attacks. Its Machamp is the 1st Edition shadowless holo, with a thick or a thin stamp (Elite Fourum). Collectors have a way of spotting sealed boxes of that printing: the two half decks are stacked in the top half of the box, the damage counters rattle loose in the bottom half, and some boxes have a gold opening strip (Elite Fourum's starter set guide).

From the next printing on, the starter set's cards had the shadow of Base Set's Unlimited print, Machamp included, but Machamp kept its stamp. That shadowed 1st Edition Machamp is the one most starter sets hold, and collectors reckon it the most common Base Set holo of all (Elite Fourum). Many call it the Unlimited Machamp, though the stamp is right there. Its stamp is nearly always the thin one: one collector has seen "maybe half a dozen" with a thick stamp. Copies with a grayish stamp turn up too, and in one collector's experience they are commoner on this card than on any other (Elite Fourum).

The last printing

Base Set's last print run, which collectors call Base Set 2000 or the 4th print, changed the copyright line on its cards to ©1999-2000. Starter sets of that run were printed in the United States and the United Kingdom, and their Machamp may have either line: one collector who opened UK-printed sets found the ©1999-2000 Machamp in some and the older ©1999 one in others (Elite Fourum). The backs of those boxes picture a Machamp without the 1st Edition stamp, a card no starter set ever held (Elite Fourum).

Brock's Machamp: no stamp, no holo

There is one Base Set Machamp without the stamp, and it isn't holo. Wizards of the Coast made two decks for the first Pokémon Leagues, Trainer Deck A (Brock's) and Trainer Deck B (Misty's). They were never sold: the box calls them tools for the Gym Leader, and they went to League leaders, not many and only for a short time (Bulbapedia). Every card in them has a red border on the back, with the deck's name printed in red.

Their fronts are Base Set's, with two exceptions. Brock's deck has a non-holo Machamp without the 1st Edition stamp, the only Unlimited Machamp there is, and Misty's has a non-holo Blastoise (Elite Fourum). The deck's Machamp has the shadow, so it isn't shadowless either (Elite Fourum).

The back of a Trainer Deck A card: a Pokémon card back with a red border and "Trainer Deck A" in red
The back of every Trainer Deck A card. Scan: Bulbapedia

Cosmos, from the wrong box

Wizards gave the English Base Set holos a foil of their own instead of the cosmos holofoil of the Japanese cards. Cosmos holo test prints have surfaced of nearly every Base Set holo, but not of Machamp, which CGC puts down to its not being in regular packs (CGC Cards).

Machamp did get a cosmos copy, though. The 2-Player CD-ROM Starter Set, sold alongside Base Set 2, held a 1st Edition Base Set Machamp in cosmos holofoil (Bulbapedia). Base Set 2 had no Machamp of its own (Elite Fourum), so the card is Base Set's 8/102, stamped and shadowed like the rest, in the Japanese foil.

For years collectors took the CD-ROM set for its only home. Then, in September 2026, a collector in the United Kingdom opened a sealed Base Set 2-Player Starter Set, the ordinary one, and found the cosmos Machamp inside, after well over fifty of those sets without one. Another collector answered that they had bought about fifty sealed Base Set starter sets in Australia a few years before and opened around thirty, and that about three in four held the cosmos copy (Elite Fourum). Collectors are still comparing boxes to work out which ones hold it.

The Machamp that never was

Look for a shadowless holo Machamp without the stamp and you may find a picture of one. It doesn't exist. Every holo Base Set Machamp is stamped, and the one copy without a stamp, Brock's, is neither holo nor shadowless (Elite Fourum).

The picture is a scan of a 1st Edition shadowless Machamp with the stamp painted out. Put it beside the scan it was made from and nothing else differs, pixel for pixel, but the small square where the stamp should be.

Two scans of Base Set Machamp side by side, identical except that the left one has no 1st Edition stamp under the picture
Left, a picture of a "shadowless" holo Machamp without the stamp. Right, the 1st Edition shadowless scan it was made from. The red boxes mark the only part that differs.

So a shadowless holo Machamp without a stamp, in a picture or in a listing, is not a card Wizards of the Coast ever printed.

Before and after

Machamp's story began in Japan, as a holo rare in the first Expansion Pack, sold in booster packs from 20 October 1996. Every card of that set came both with and without a rarity star, and collectors take the starless print, known as No Rarity, for the earlier one (Bulbapedia).

English collectors had to wait until Legendary Collection in May 2002 to find Machamp in a booster pack. Its reprint rewords the Pokémon Power, Strikes Back, for Special Conditions where Base Set's listed Asleep, Confused or Paralyzed (Bulbapedia), and Legendary Collection was the first set with reverse holos, foil everywhere but the picture, in a fireworks pattern (Bulbapedia). Ken Sugimori's painting came back once more in XY Evolutions in 2016.

Sources